Alternative Engagement Rings

Alternative Engagement Rings

Our unconventional alternative rings feature handcrafted designs and extraordinary materials. Celebrate your extraordinary relationship with an alternative engagement ring today.

Sort by

$
$
Match all
Match all
Twisted Moissanite Engagement Ring in 14k White Gold with Meteorite and Diamond Accents
Twisted Moissanite Engagement Ring in 14k White Gold with Meteorite and Diamond Accents
$648.17/month or $3,889.00 total
Rough Diamond Engagement Ring, Meteorite Ring In Wavy White Gold Design-3427 - Jewelry by Johan
Rough Diamond Engagement Ring, Meteorite Ring with Wavy Design
$535.83/month or $3,215.00 total
Meteorite and Moissanite Engagement
Three Stone Engagement Ring With Meteorite, Twisting Shank Ring
$761.50/month or $4,569.00 total
Emerald Cut Engagement Ring with Meteorite
Emerald Cut Solitaire Engagement Ring with Meteorite
$583.17/month or $3,499.00 total
Oval Cut Solitaire Engagement Ring with Meteorite in Rose Gold-4543RG - Jewelry by Johan
Oval Cut Solitaire Engagement Ring with Meteorite
$629.83/month or $3,779.00 total
Meteorite & White Sapphire Engagement Ring
Meteorite & White Sapphire Engagement Ring
$333.17/month or $1,999.00 total
Oval Halo Moissanite & Meteorite Engagement Ring-4542 - Jewelry by Johan
Meteorite & Oval Halo Moissanite Engagement Ring
$658.17/month or $3,949.00 total
Gibeon Meteorite Engagement Ring with Tension Set Stone
Gibeon Meteorite Engagement Ring with Tension Set Stone
$409.83/month or $2,459.00 total
Meteorite, Moonstone & Moissanite Three Stone Engagement Ring
Meteorite, Moonstone & Moissanite Three Stone Engagement Ring
$679.83/month or $4,079.00 total
White Gold Aquamarine Engagement Ring
Rough Aquamarine Engagement Ring With Meteorite in White Gold
$464.17/month or $2,785.00 total
Meteorite and Black Diamond Wedding Band
Black Diamond Engagement Ring With Meteorite Stone
$332.50/month or $1,995.00 total
Aquamarine and Meteorite Engagement Ring
Three Stone Meteorite Engagement Ring With Aquamarine
$349.83/month or $2,099.00 total
Aquamarine Engagement Ring, Meteorite In Wavy White Gold-3251 - Jewelry by Johan
Rough Aquamarine Engagement Ring with Meteorite
$816.50/month or $4,899.00 total
Alexandrite Engagement Ring With Moonstones, Alternative Engagement Ring-2742 - Jewelry by Johan
Alexandrite, Moonstone & Meteorite Engagement Ring
$869.83/month or $5,219.00 total
Meteorite Engagement Ring With Tension Set Stone
Meteorite Engagement Ring With Tension Set Stone
$298.17/month or $1,789.00 total
Three Stone Moissanite & Meteorite Engagement Ring - Jewelry by Johan
Three Stone Moissanite & Meteorite Engagement Ring
$409.83/month or $2,459.00 total
Moonstone Engagement Ring, Rose Gold Meteorite Ring-2632 - Jewelry by Johan
Moonstone & Meteorite Engagement Ring With Twist Design
$1,321.50/month or $7,929.00 total
Princess Cut Peridot & Meteorite Engagement Ring - Jewelry by Johan
Princess-Cut Peridot & Meteorite Engagement Ring
$889.83/month or $5,339.00 total
Rough Diamond Engagement Ring with Dinosaur Bone
Rough Diamond Engagement Ring with Dinosaur Bone
$1,008.17/month or $6,049.00 total
Pear Cut Moissanite Engagement Ring With A Twist Shank - Jewelry by Johan
Pear Cut Moissanite Engagement Ring With A Twist Shank
$1,039.83/month or $6,239.00 total

Alternative Rings for Engagements & Weddings

Explore distinctive expressions of love with our alternative ring collection, where creativity meets craftsmanship. From unique designs to customizable options, each piece is a testament to individuality, ensuring a symbol of commitment as extraordinary as your love. Browse our huge selection of hand-crafted alternative ring designs today.

Whether you're looking for an engagement ring featuring a unique material inlay such as meteorite or a diamond alternative like opal, you can find an abundance of options here. Or, customize any of the designs you see here to make it your dream ring.

Have an idea for your dream ring? Contact us to get a custom engagement ring using our extraordinary options or personal sentimental materials. You can even make your jewelry truly special by sending in your own deer antler, gemstone or other item.

Jewelry by Johan: Unique Engagement Jewelry for All

Jewelry by Johan stands out as a distinguished ring seller, creating engagement rings inspired by nature and love since 2008. With over 200,000 satisfied customers globally, our USA-based handcrafted approach ensures the highest quality and precision.

We specialize in extraordinary materials such as meteorite, dinosaur bone and more. Meet our team and learn more about our journey to crafting luxury jewelry here.

Alternative Engagement Rings FAQs

What defines an “alternative” engagement ring?

Alternative rings use unconventional materials like meteorite, antler, dinosaur bone, turquoise, wood, or unique gemstones for a bold, one-of-a-kind look.

Can I supply my own materials for an alternative ring?

Yes, in many cases we can incorporate personal materials—such as wood, antler, or even stones—after review and approval. A signed waiver will be required.

Can I customize a design to combine traditional and alternative elements?

Definitely. Many clients choose hybrid styles, pairing classic diamond settings with unique inlays like meteorite or wood.

How do I care for alternative material rings?
  • Meteorite: Keep dry, oil lightly, and use care kits.
  • Antler/Wood: Avoid prolonged water exposure.
  • Gemstones: Clean gently and avoid ultrasonic cleaners for softer stones.

Or view the Jewelry Care Instructions

Johan Rust at Jewelry by Johan

Still have questions?

Can't find the answers you're looking for? Please get in touch with our friendly team.

Book a Free Consultation 1-on-1 design session, by phone, video, or in-person

Jewelry by Johan is superb to work with! From the quality of the product, the workmanship, responsiveness and superior customer service, our entire experience was exceptional!

Angela T.