Men's Engagement Rings

The men's engagement ring is a powerful, visible symbol of commitment and a promise of forever. Finding the right commitment ring for men means choosing a style that truly speaks to his personality. At Jewelry by Johan, we specialize in both timeless engagement rings with unique materials and deeply personalized styles. We use rare materials like genuine Meteorite and fossilized Dinosaur Bone to create a lasting testament to your love.

Modern Engagement Rings Designed for Him

The standard for men’s jewelry is changing! Men’s rings have come a long way since Jewelry by Johan first began in a garage. Gone are the days when a simple gold band was the only option. Today, a male engagement ring holds the same significant meaning as its traditional counterpart, serving as a beautiful, modern marker of a couple's journey before the wedding day. Our collection of modern engagement rings for men caters to a desire for something beyond the traditional, embracing your own style.

We believe that a commitment ring should be as unique as the man wearing it. This is why our extensive collection includes a wide range of designs, ensuring there is a perfect match for every taste and lifestyle. Whether he prefers a masculine signet ring design with an inlay of meteorite or dinosaur bone, or a sleek design with a small bezel-set stone in precious metal, you can either find it here or customize it into existence! We can even work with a material that you send in, like a golf tee, a trophy deer antler from a hunting trip, a cut of wood from a tree branch, a stave of whiskey barrel, a guitar string, or anything that you feel represents who you are.

Our designs offer everything from durable alternative metals to elegant men's diamond rings, all crafted to be comfortable and distinctive. Explore rings made with masculine metals and unique inlays that celebrate his individuality. Choosing a unique men's engagement ring is an exciting step, and our handcrafted pieces are designed to become treasured heirlooms. If you’d like to personalize your men’s jewelry, just click “Customize This Item” in any listing and let us know what you’d like to add or change!

Why Choose Men’s Engagement Rings from Jewelry by Johan?

When you’re looking for the perfect ring to symbolize commitment, you need a jeweler you can trust. Here are a few reasons why customers choose us for their men’s promise rings and engagement jewelry for him:

-Exclusivity in Every Design: We specialize in crafting men's rings with extraordinary materials that make for truly one-of-a-kind pieces. Imagine a ring inlaid with authenticated Gibeon meteorite or fossilized dinosaur bone, linking your promise to deep history. These rare materials create symbols of commitment that are as unmatched and enduring as your love.

-Artisan, Handcrafted Quality: We’re a family-owned, artisan business. Every ring is meticulously handcrafted in Minnesota. Our team are not just jewelers; we are experts in guiding anyone through our process, helping you create a custom men’s engagement ring that is exactly what you envision. If you have any doubts, check out our reviews and testimonials(https://jewelrybyjohan.com/pages/testimonials-and-reviews) from all over the world from 2008 to now.

-Ethically Sourced Materials: You can shop with confidence knowing that all diamonds and precious gemstones used in our designs are conflict-free and ethically sourced. Beyond stones, we use ethically harvested wood and naturally shed deer antler, maintaining a commitment to responsible practices in every facet of our business.

-Worry-Free Sizing and Fit: Ordering custom, non-resizable rings online can be nerve-wracking, but we take the anxiety out of the process. We use a meticulous, three-step sizing process to ensure a perfect fit before the final production of your custom-made engagement ring. To start, just purchase our ring sizing program(https://jewelrybyjohan.com/products/custom-sizer-program-assured-accuracy) alongside your ring, initiating this simple process:

-We ship a sizing kit first for you to get an estimated sizing range. This kit has many sizes in it, so you can test out different ones. You’ll let us know which one felt best! You can skip this step if you already know your estimated size. (Sizes from another store can only be an estimated size at-best, due to potential differences in tools).

-We then ship you custom ring sizers that fit one size above and one size below your reported estimated size. These are made to match the width and fit of your final ring, making them very accurate to how it’ll feel to wear. Again, you’ll let us know which of these fit you best, though we suggest wearing each of these for at least 1-2 days since your finger changes size throughout the day.

-We make your custom men's engagement ring according to our current turnaround time! And you get to rest easy knowing that your ring will be made in the best size for you.

FAQs About Engagement Rings for Men

When considering a male commitment band, you may have questions about tradition, design, and purchasing a ring that will last a lifetime. Here are the answers to the most common questions about engagement rings for men. If anything you’re wondering isn’t on this list, or if you want more information, please don’t hesitate to contact us!

Men's Engagement Rings FAQs

What is the difference between a man's engagement ring and a wedding band?

Traditionally, the engagement ring is presented at the proposal to signify the promise to marry, and the wedding band is exchanged during the ceremony. However, for men's jewelry, these lines are often blurred. Many couples choose a single, unique ring that serves as both the male engagement ring and wedding band. Whether you decide to get a men’s engagement ring or a men’s wedding band, our expertise will ensure that it’s one of a kind. You can explore our collection of men's wedding bands for more ideas.

Can I create a fully custom design for the engagement ring?

Absolutely. Creating a fully custom design is a core service at Jewelry by Johan. We specialize in bringing unique visions to life, crafting bespoke engagement rings that incorporate everything from traditional metals to the extremely unique. Start the process of designing your custom men's engagement ring by scheduling a free online custom jewelry consultation. Or, click “Customize This Item” in any listing to let us know what you’d like to change about it.

Can I provide my own materials for my ring?

Yes, we specialize in working with customer provided materials. Whether it’s an heirloom stone, a sentimental piece of wood, flowers from your garden, or really almost anything, we’d happily put it into your custom jewelry design! We invite you to make your handmade men's ring truly personal and meaningful. Simply fill out the “Send an Item to JBJ for Custom Work” form , and we’ll send you instructions for shipping your materials once we process your submission. We treat whatever you send in with extreme care, and we will let you know if we can use it before starting work on your custom men's engagement ring. We always return any unused material to you.

How much should you spend on a man's engagement ring?

The old "two months' salary" rule is an outdated marketing tactic and should be ignored. The amount you spend on a men's engagement ring should be based on what you are comfortable with and the sentimental value the ring holds. A ring's significance comes from the promise it represents, not its price tag. Jewelry by Johan offers men's commitment bands across a wide price range, from durable alternative metal rings to elegant, diamond-set men's engagement band designs, ensuring there is a meaningful option for every budget. We have high expectations from our materials, so budget friendly designs (like rings with titanium and wood, for instance) are built to last

What’s the most accurate way to find my ring size?

We have a dedicated Custom Sizer Program to take the guesswork out of finding the right size for your custom men's ring. If you purchase the program alongside your ring, we’ll automatically send you a sizing kit to start the process. You can read more on the steps in its listing.

The reason to get the program is so we’ll make you custom sizers in the width and fit of your final ring. This is why a custom sizer is the best way to find your ring size accurately, since it will actually feel like the final ring. We suggest wearing it for a couple days to get a sense for what it’s like over the course of the day (your finger changes size throughout the day due to things like temperature, water, and diet!)

The custom sizer we make for you is like an insurance policy. If you choose not to order the custom ring sizers, you would need to pay the re-make fee if the ring doesn't fit upon arrival. However, if you confirmed your ring size with our custom sizers and the ring you received still doesn’t fit for whatever reason, we would re-make the ring for you at no charge.

Still have questions?

Can't find the answers you're looking for? Please get in touch with our friendly team.

Book a Free Consultation 1-on-1 design session, by phone, video, or in-person

Jewelry by Johan is superb to work with! From the quality of the product, the workmanship, responsiveness and superior customer service, our entire experience was exceptional!

Angela T.

Your cart